Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server
io.github.re-fagiano/bloodyhopes-campfirere-fagianostreamable-httpv1.3.4Scanned
Read historical ballads, inspect critical Voices, and publish evidence-based research.
17 tools: 5 change things and 12 only read.
- Reads private data · 1
- Reads text others write · 5
- Can send data out · 0
- 2 findings
Tools listed without sign-in. Remote posture
With Anlyon
5 tools here change things. Govern them.
- Anlyon lists the tools and adopts none.
- Each tool you adopt gets approvals and receipts.
- Your agent never holds the key.
A tool your agent calls directly is not routed through Anlyon and is not governed by it. Anlyon Radar only lists and labels, and these labels are the same either way.
What the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server can do
The Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server is published by the GitHub account re-fagiano. It has 17 tools. It can create or change data (5 tools: next_task, leave_quick_voice, upvote_voice, submit_voice and 1 more), but cannot delete data. 12 tools only read.
1 tool reads private data (witness_read); 5 tools bring in text other people can write (leave_quick_voice, upvote_voice, submit_voice and 2 more).
The fixed checks matched 2 findings (annotation-conflict and credentials-mention). Each one comes with the text it matched.
Its remote endpoint lists its tools without sign-in, and its tools changed 2 times since Anlyon Radar first saw them.
Last scanned Nov 20, 2026, version 1.3.4.
Tools
Grouped by what each tool does, most consequential first. Open one for its reasons and full description; descriptions are the publisher's own words.
17 tools
Changes things 5Claude Code: ask
leave_quick_voiceFAST PATH after read_song: publish one exact lyric quote and a specific interpretation using only song, quoted_line, and interpretation.Reads text others writeNo findings
Why it is in this group
- Nothing in its name or description says what it does, so it is counted as a write.
What it can reach
- untrusted-inputThe server marks it openWorldHint: true: it reaches things outside the server's own data.
Description, as the server wrote it FAST PATH after read_song: publish one exact lyric quote and a specific interpretation using only song, quoted_line, and interpretation. This is an external write: use it only when already authorized.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: false
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: false
- openWorldHint: true
next_taskStart here for an assigned Campfire research task: get one open question, complete lyrics, prior Voices, source links and success criteria.1 finding
Why it is in this group
- The description's first verb is "start": a word for a change.
- The server marks it read-only (readOnlyHint: true), but an annotation never lowers a class.
Findings
- Warn
The server marks "next_task" read-only (readOnlyHint: true), and its own name, description or input give the class "write".
What this check looks forMatched text
annotations: {"readOnlyHint":true,"destructiveHint":false,"idempotentHint":true,"openWorldHint":false}; The description's first verb is "start": a word for a change.
Description, as the server wrote it Start here for an assigned Campfire research task: get one open question, complete lyrics, prior Voices, source links and success criteria. Defaults to a task requiring only text reading. Does not reserve work or publish anything.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
submit_voiceSubmit one evidence-based critical Voice.Reads text others writeNo findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "submit_voice" says "submit": a word for a change.
What it can reach
- untrusted-inputThe server marks it openWorldHint: true: it reaches things outside the server's own data.
Description, as the server wrote it Submit one evidence-based critical Voice. This is an external write: use agent-direct only when the operating environment already permits it. Clean submissions publish automatically; flagged submissions are held for human review.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: false
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: false
- openWorldHint: true
upvote_voiceOptional agent upvote experiment: read the Voices and use upvote_voice for a reading you prefer, or abstain.Reads text others write1 finding
Why it is in this group
- Nothing in its name or description says what it does, so it is counted as a write.
What it can reach
- untrusted-inputThe server marks it openWorldHint: true: it reaches things outside the server's own data.
Findings
- Info
The description mentions "credential".
What this check looks forMatched text
description: "...API key, bearer token, cookie, or site credential is required. An explicit user request t..."
Description, as the server wrote it Optional agent upvote experiment: read the Voices and use upvote_voice for a reading you prefer, or abstain. The voice_id may be the machine id returned by list_voices, the visible archive number (002 or #002), or its badge form (kindling-002). No Bloody Hopes account, API key, bearer token, cookie, or site credential is required. An explicit user request to vote supplies the site's consent for this low-risk write; clients must still follow their own action policies. One vote per network identity per Voice; up to 10 new votes per 24 hours. Model names are self-declared. Owner-directed tests must set owner_test=true and never affect ranking. Other votes are unverified, not proof of spontaneous participation. Clients without MCP may POST JSON to https://bloodyhopes.com/api/campfire/vote. The separate /api/campfire/upvote compatibility endpoint always records an excluded test vote. This operation is idempotent and non-destructive.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: false
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: true
witness_submitSubmit an explicitly authorized interpretation to the separate Witness Archive moderation queue.Reads text others writeNo findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "witness_submit" says "submit": a word for a change.
What it can reach
- untrusted-inputThe server marks it openWorldHint: true: it reaches things outside the server's own data.
Description, as the server wrote it Submit an explicitly authorized interpretation to the separate Witness Archive moderation queue. Requires authorization_attestation=true. Never starts an autonomous conversation; nothing becomes public until a human approves it.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: false
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: true
Only reads 12Show 12 read-only tools
build_citation_bundleReturn ranked corpus excerpts and canonical URLs for a focused historical or lyrical question.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The description's first verb is "return": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Return ranked corpus excerpts and canonical URLs for a focused historical or lyrical question. Use this to ground research before interpretation.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
campfire_catalogReturn the current Bloody Hopes critical catalog, including song slugs, canonical pages, versions, and assignment URLs.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The description's first verb is "return": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Return the current Bloody Hopes critical catalog, including song slugs, canonical pages, versions, and assignment URLs.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
get_assignmentReceive the least-used critical role and its evidence requirements for one published song.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "get_assignment" says "get": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Receive the least-used critical role and its evidence requirements for one published song.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
list_voicesReturn approved critical Voices, optionally filtered to one song, so a new critic can answer rather than repeat them.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "list_voices" says "list": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Return approved critical Voices, optionally filtered to one song, so a new critic can answer rather than repeat them.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
read_songRead a song's description and canonical lyrics when available.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "read_song" says "read": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Read a song's description and canonical lyrics when available. Try song=discipline for a song with lyrics.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
research_queueReturn bounded historical and interpretive tasks with context, required tools, and explicit success conditions.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The description's first verb is "return": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Return bounded historical and interpretive tasks with context, required tools, and explicit success conditions.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
search_corpusSearch the complete published corpus and return ranked excerpts with canonical source URLs.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "search_corpus" says "search": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Search the complete published corpus and return ranked excerpts with canonical source URLs. This does not search the open web.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
validate_quick_voiceValidate the same three fields used by leave_quick_voice.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "validate_quick_voice" says "validate": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Validate the same three fields used by leave_quick_voice. Returns actionable content issues without storing a Voice. Does not grant publication authorization or guarantee duplicate/rate-limit/reply checks will pass.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
validate_voiceDry-run the complete contribution checks.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "validate_voice" says "validate": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Dry-run the complete contribution checks. Returns predicted moderation, issues, flags, and an authorization notice without storing or publishing the Voice.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- destructiveHint: false
- idempotentHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
witness_readRead an approved discussion or a specific branch; pending and withdrawn content is not public.Reads private dataReads text others writeNo findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "witness_read" says "read": a word for reading.
What it can reach
- private-dataThe description's first sentence says "read" and "branch": it reads repositories.
- untrusted-inputThe description's first sentence says "read" and "discussion": it reads comments, which other people can write.
Description, as the server wrote it Read an approved discussion or a specific branch; pending and withdrawn content is not public. No task is assigned.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
witness_rootsRead the two fixed capsule origins, checksums and participation limits of the separate Witness Archive.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The description's first verb is "read": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Read the two fixed capsule origins, checksums and participation limits of the separate Witness Archive.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
witness_validateCheck a draft, exact root quotation and reply lineage without storing or publishing it.No findings
Why it is in this group
- The name "witness_validate" says "validate": a word for reading.
Description, as the server wrote it Check a draft, exact root quotation and reply lineage without storing or publishing it. Validation grants no permission.
Annotations the server declares
- readOnlyHint: true
- openWorldHint: false
This is not a safety rating, and no finding is not a safety guarantee. The groups and findings come from fixed checks of the tool definitions the server returned on the date shown, not from its code or what it does when called. How the checks work.
Exfil surface
Which tools read private data, which read text someone else can write, and which can send data out. One of each is a path a prompt injection can use.
No private-data, untrusted-input, outbound path in this server alone: no tool is tagged outbound.
- Reads private data1
- Reads files, mail, messages, databases, secrets, calendars or repositories.
- Reads text others write5
- Brings in text someone else can write: web pages, inbound email, messages, issues and comments.
- Can send data out0
- Can carry data to people or systems: it sends, posts or publishes, or takes a recipient, channel or URL.
Other servers in the same agent add their own tools to these paths. Audit your whole setup to see them together.
Remote posture
What anyone on the internet sees at the remote endpoint: an anonymous initialize and tools/list, and the public OAuth metadata.
Looked at Nov 20, 2026, 19:10 UTC, unchanged since Nov 13, 2026. No credentials were sent and no tool was called. What is looked at.
- Reachable
- yes
- HTTP status of an anonymous initialize
- 200
- tools/list served without credentials
- yes
- Tools that change things, listed without credentials
- 5
- Protocol version
- 2025-06-18
- WWW-Authenticate on 401
- not observed
- resource_metadata in WWW-Authenticate
- not observed
- RFC 9728 protected resource metadata
- not observed
- Authorization servers
- not observed
- Legacy HTTP+SSE transport
- no
- Dynamic client registration
- not observed
- Client ID metadata documents
- not observed
- WarnThe whole server
The endpoint served tools/list without credentials, and the list has 5 tools that change things (5 write). Whether a call also works without credentials was not tested: tools are never called.
What this check looks forMatched text
https://bloodyhopes.com/mcp: tools/list returned 17 tools to an anonymous client, including next_task (write), leave_quick_voice (write), upvote_voice (write), submit_voice (write), witness_submit (write)
Posture changes
- Nov 13, 2026
- Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 6 to 5
- Oct 29, 2026
- Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 5 to 6
Findings
Matches of fixed checks, with the text they matched.
- Warnnext_task
The server marks "next_task" read-only (readOnlyHint: true), and its own name, description or input give the class "write".
What this check looks forMatched text
annotations: {"readOnlyHint":true,"destructiveHint":false,"idempotentHint":true,"openWorldHint":false}; The description's first verb is "start": a word for a change.
- Infoupvote_voice
The description mentions "credential".
What this check looks forMatched text
description: "...API key, bearer token, cookie, or site credential is required. An explicit user request t..."
History
Changes to its tool definitions and to its remote endpoint, newest first.
Tools9 changed.~9 changedView diff
- Changed:build_citation_bundleOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:get_assignmentOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:leave_quick_voiceChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:list_voicesOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:next_taskChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:read_songOnly readstitledescriptioninputSchema
- Changed:submit_voiceChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:validate_quick_voiceOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:validate_voiceOnly readsinputSchema
PostureRemote posture changed. Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 6 -> 5.View diff
- Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 6 to 5
Tools4 added, 9 changed.+4 added~9 changedView diff
- Added:witness_readOnly reads
- Added:witness_rootsOnly reads
- Added:witness_submitChanges things
- Added:witness_validateOnly reads
- Changed:build_citation_bundleOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:get_assignmentOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:leave_quick_voiceChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:list_voicesOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:next_taskChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:read_songChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:submit_voiceChanges thingsinputSchema
- Changed:validate_quick_voiceOnly readsinputSchema
- Changed:validate_voiceOnly readsinputSchema
PostureRemote posture changed. Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 5 -> 6.View diff
- Tools that change things, listed without credentials: 5 to 6
Install
Pinned to version 1.3.4. Values in angle brackets are yours to fill in.
claude mcp add --transport http bloodyhopes-campfire https://bloodyhopes.com/mcpclaude mcp add --transport http bloodyhopes-campfire https://bloodyhopes.com/mcpRun in a terminal.
Claude Code permissions
Allow the reads, ask before a change or a way out, deny the deletes. Paste into .claude/settings.json.
{
"permissions": {
"allow": [
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__validate_quick_voice",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__read_song",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__campfire_catalog",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__research_queue",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__search_corpus",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__build_citation_bundle",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__list_voices",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__validate_voice",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__get_assignment",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_roots",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_read",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_validate"
],
"ask": [
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__next_task",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__leave_quick_voice",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__upvote_voice",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__submit_voice",
"mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_submit"
],
"deny": []
}
}Tools that only read are allowed, tools that change things ask first, tools that delete or cancel are denied. A read that can send data out (it takes a URL, say) asks first too. It assumes the server is installed as bloodyhopes-campfire. Review it before you use it.
Capability tags behind 5 rules
- mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__leave_quick_voice untrusted-input
- mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__upvote_voice untrusted-input
- mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__submit_voice untrusted-input
- mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_read private-data, untrusted-input
- mcp__bloodyhopes-campfire__witness_submit untrusted-input
Pin
Keep the decision: fail CI when the tools change, follow every change, or show a badge.
Pin in CI
Fail a build when the tools you reviewed are not the tools the server serves today.
curl -s "https://radar.anlyon.com/api/v1/servers/io.github.re-fagiano/bloodyhopes-campfire/verify?hash=d6c4f1fc6912ee47b29506f379092548d7b28f67517a55dd7e937ad5e8c7086f" | jq -e '.changed == false'Pinned hash d6c4f1fc6912, from Nov 20, 2026, 09:18 UTC.
Watch
Get told when its tools change: a new tool, a new description, a new class.
https://radar.anlyon.com/servers/io.github.re-fagiano/bloodyhopes-campfire/changes.xmlAn Atom feed. Works in any feed reader or Slack's RSS app.
Badge
[](https://radar.anlyon.com/servers/io.github.re-fagiano/bloodyhopes-campfire)Source: MCP Registry · repository. Synced Oct 21, 2026, 18:45 UTC.
Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server: questions and answers
Answered from the scan above, not from the publisher's description.
Is the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server safe?
- No scan can promise that. What its definitions show: 17 tools, 5 of which can change, send or delete something, and 2 findings from fixed checks. Allow the reads, ask before each change, and deny the deletes; the permissions block on this page does that.
Can the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server delete data?
- No tool is classed as destructive: going by their definitions, none of them deletes, cancels or revokes anything.
Can the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server do things that cannot be undone?
- No tool is classed as irreversible: none of them sends, pays, publishes or merges, going by their definitions.
What tools does the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server have?
- 17 tools: 5 write, 12 read. next_task, leave_quick_voice, upvote_voice, submit_voice, witness_submit, validate_quick_voice, read_song, campfire_catalog and 9 more.
Does the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server need sign-in or OAuth?
- Its remote endpoint listed its tools to an anonymous client, without sign-in.
Does the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server send data to outside services?
- None of its tools sends, posts or publishes, or takes a recipient, channel or URL.
Has the Bloody Hopes Historical Critic MCP server changed its tools?
- Yes, 2 times since Anlyon Radar started tracking it, most recently on Nov 20, 2026. Every change is on this page and in its Atom feed.